The Pie Hole Menu (Update 2025)

Introducing The Pie Hole, a must-visit pizza and sandwich shop located at 320 Mayville Rd, Bethel, ME. Esteemed for their exceptional offerings, The Pie Hole serves both traditional and specialty pizzas, including the popular Buffalo Chicken Pie and the hearty Meat Lovah, each bursting with flavor. Their 10" GF Cauliflower Crust alternative appeals to gluten-sensitive patrons, though it's important to note it’s not prepared in a gluten-free environment.

Beyond pizzas, the sub menu shines with options like the Meatball Sub and the flavorful Italian Sub, all prepared with fresh ingredients. Customers rave about the quick service and friendly staff, making it a favorite for both locals and visitors at Sunday River. Whether you're grabbing a quick meal or enjoying a leisurely bite outside, The Pie Hole promises delicious comfort food that keeps you coming back for more!

PIZZA

12" Small

$9.25

16" Large

$16.00

Toppings

Pepperoni Bacon Italian Sausage Meatball Ham Hamburger Prosciutto Green Pepper White Onion Tomato Black Olive Fresh Sliced Mushrooms Broccoli Banana Pepper Minced Garlic Fresh Mozzarella Feta Pineapple Basil

$1.50

10" GF Cauliflower Crust

*Not prepared in a gluten-free environment. Contains cheese.

$10.00

The Italian

fresh-sliced ham, salami, provolone or american cheese, veggies

$11.11

Veggie Italian

your choice of fresh veggies, with or without provolone or american cheese

$9.00

Meatball Sub

meatballs, sauce, sliced mozzarella cheese, toasted

$11.11

Steak And Cheese Sub

shaved sirloin, green pepper. onion, american cheese, with or without mayo

$13.00

SUBS

SPECIALTY PIES

Supreme Pie

pepperoni, sausage, green pepper. onion, black olives, oregano

$14.50

The Luau

BBQ base with prosciutto, bacon. pineapple

$12.50

Big Jay

double dough, double pepperoni

$12.50

Veggie Pie

tomato, green pepper, onion. black olives, fresh sliced mushrooms

$12.50

Meat Lovah

pepperoni, sausage, bacon, meatball, ham

$14.50

Pesto Tee's Pie

pesto base, prosciutto, broccoli, feta

$12.50

Chicken Bacon Ranch

ranch base with crispy chicken and bacon

$12.50

BBQ Chicken Pi

BBQ base with BBQ chicken

$12.50

Buffalo Chicken

ranch base with buffalo chicken and buffalo drizzle

$12.50

Spicy Italian Panini

ham. salami, provolone cheese. veggies, spicy relish

$11.11

Grilled Cheese

your choice of american. provolone, or swiss cheese

$6.00

Reuben

corned beef, sauerkraut, swiss and thousand island on marble rye

$11.11

PANINI SANDWICHES